AdsFlair

Guides / PPC Strategy

PPC Strategy

Performance Max vs Search Ads for UK Local Service Businesses: Where Should Your Budget Actually Go?

How the two campaign types find customers, what the 2025 Performance Max updates changed, what lead-quality data shows, and a budget split that suits local trades.

By the AdsFlair team · Updated October 2026 · 6 min read

Woman comparing two bar charts on a monitor

Google recommends Performance Max to almost every advertiser, and many local businesses switch it on because the Google rep or an agency suggested it. Some see cheaper leads. Others see a flood of form-fills from people who never answer the phone. Both outcomes are common, and the difference usually comes down to tracking, budget and how much of the account is still running on Search.

How they differ

Search campaignsPerformance Max
Where ads showGoogle search results (and optionally search partners)Search, Maps, YouTube, Display, Discover and Gmail, from one campaign
How targeting worksYour keywords, match types and negativesGoogle's AI, guided by assets, audience signals and search themes
ControlHigh: you choose searches, ads and pagesLower: you guide, Google decides placement
ReportingFull search terms and keyword dataImproved in 2025, still less granular
Typical leadSomeone searching for the serviceA mix of searchers and people browsing other Google properties

What changed in Performance Max in 2025

Performance Max became much easier to control during 2025. According to PPC Land's summary of Google's rollouts:

Performance Max vs Search
Performance Max vs Search
  • Campaign-level negative keywords began rolling out in January 2025, with the limit raised to 10,000 negative keywords in March.
  • Channel-level performance reporting and fuller search terms visibility arrived from April 2025, so you can see how much went to Search versus YouTube or Display.
  • Search themes per asset group doubled from 25 to 50.
  • Demographic exclusions and device targeting moved to general availability.

Those changes remove some of the strongest objections local advertisers had. They do not change the fundamental trade: Performance Max still decides more for you than Search does.

What the lead-quality data shows

There is little public UK data, but one US dataset is useful. SearchLight Digital's January 2026 figures for 816 HVAC and plumbing contractors, as reported by The AdSpend, compared campaign types:

Campaign typeCost per leadBooking rateCost per booked job (derived)
Branded search$3455.3%~$61
Performance Max$7232.2%~$224
Non-branded search$14937.6%~$396

US data from one vendor's client base, not an industry-wide survey. Cost per booked job calculated as cost per lead divided by booking rate.

Two lessons come out of this. Performance Max produced cheaper leads than non-branded search and, in this dataset, a lower cost per booked job too. But its leads booked at a lower rate, and part of Performance Max spend often goes on searches for your own brand, which would have converted cheaply anyway. If PMax is quietly taking credit for brand searches, its numbers look better than its real contribution.

When Search should get most of the budget

  • Budgets under about £1,500 a month. Performance Max needs data across several channels; small budgets spread thin.
  • Urgent, phone-led services. Emergency plumbing, locksmiths, drainage, boiler repairs: people search, they do not browse YouTube for a plumber.
  • Strict service areas or job types. Search keywords and negatives give tighter control.
  • Tracking still counts all calls and forms. PMax optimises hard for whatever conversion you give it; with weak tracking it finds the easiest form-fillers.

When Performance Max earns a place

  • Higher-value planned work such as solar, kitchens, landscaping and home improvements, where visual assets on YouTube and Display help people decide.
  • Accounts with imported qualified leads or booked jobs as the primary conversion.
  • Strong creative: real photos and short videos of your work, not stock images.
  • Search already covers the core keywords well, and you want extra reach.

Set Performance Max up so it does not cannibalise Search

  1. Exclude your brand using brand exclusions, and run a separate brand Search campaign. Otherwise PMax claims cheap brand conversions.
  2. Add account-level and campaign-level negative keywords for jobs, DIY and services you do not offer.
  3. Use only real enquiries as conversions, ideally qualified leads imported from your CRM.
  4. Target presence in your area, not interest, in location options.
  5. Turn off final URL expansion or exclude blog and info pages.
  6. Check channel reporting monthly. If most spend goes to Display with few conversions, the campaign needs tighter signals or a smaller budget.

A sensible budget split

Monthly ad budgetSearchPerformance Max
Under £1,500100%0% (test later)
£1,500 to £4,00070 to 80%20 to 30% as a test
£4,000+ with booked jobs tracked50 to 70%30 to 50%

Starting points for local service businesses. Adjust by cost per booked job after 60 to 90 days.

How to judge the test

Do not compare cost per lead alone. For each campaign, report leads, booking rate, cost per booked job and the share of spend on brand searches. If Performance Max looks cheaper but books fewer jobs, or most of its conversions are brand searches, Search is doing the real work.

For the newest automation in Search campaigns, read AI Max for Google Ads: on or off?, and for lead quality issues see Google Ads leads but no sales.

How to structure Performance Max for a local service business

Performance Max is organised into asset groups. For a local business, one asset group per main service works best, each with its own images, video, headlines and audience signals.

Asset groupFinal URLSearch themes (examples)Audience signal
Boiler installation/boiler-installation/new boiler cost, boiler replacement, combi boiler installationWebsite visitors to installation pages; customer list
Heat pumps/heat-pumps/air source heat pump installer, heat pump grantPeople who visited heat pump pages
Servicing/boiler-service/boiler service near me, annual boiler servicePast customers

Use your own photos and short phone-shot videos of real jobs. If you do not upload a video, Google may build one from your images, and auto-generated videos rarely represent a trade business well.

Reading the channel performance report

Since 2025, Performance Max shows how spend and conversions split across Search, YouTube, Display, Discover, Gmail and Maps. For a local service account, a healthy pattern usually has most conversions coming from Search and Maps. Warning signs:

  • A large share of spend on Display with few conversions, or with conversions that turn out to be accidental form-fills.
  • Conversions concentrated in brand searches, which suggests PMax is taking credit for people who were already looking for you.
  • YouTube spend with no view-through value you can see in booked jobs.

The brand cannibalisation check, step by step

  1. Open the Performance Max search terms report (or search term insights) for the last 30 days.
  2. Filter for your company name and common misspellings.
  3. Add up the conversions from those searches as a share of the campaign's total.
  4. If brand searches make up a large share, add a brand exclusion to Performance Max and run brand as its own Search campaign.
  5. Compare total conversions across the account for the four weeks before and after. If the total holds steady, PMax was mostly relabelling brand traffic.

A realistic test plan

WeekAction
0Fix tracking, set brand exclusion, add negatives, choose one service
1 to 2Launch with 20 to 30% of budget; leave settings alone while it learns
3 to 4Check channel and search term reports; add negatives
5 to 8Compare cost per booked job against Search for the same service
9+Scale, hold or stop, based on booked jobs rather than leads

Want this set up and run for you? See our PPC management.

Frequently asked questions

Is Performance Max good for local service businesses?

It can be for higher-value planned work with strong visual assets and reliable conversion tracking. For urgent, phone-led services and small budgets, Search campaigns usually give better control and lead quality.

Can I add negative keywords to Performance Max?

Yes. Campaign-level negative keywords rolled out in 2025, with Google raising the limit to 10,000 negative keywords. Brand exclusions are also available.

Why are my Performance Max leads poor quality?

Usually because conversion tracking counts every form or call, location settings include people interested in your area, or the campaign spends heavily on Display. Import qualified leads and check channel reporting.

How should I split budget between Search and Performance Max?

Under about £1,500 a month, keep it on Search. Above that, test Performance Max with 20 to 30% of budget and compare cost per booked job after 60 to 90 days.

Related guides

Sources

  1. PPC Land, "Google wraps up Performance Max feature rollouts in 2025"
  2. The AdSpend, Google Ads search benchmarks for HVAC (SearchLight Digital US data, January 2026)

Is Performance Max taking credit it has not earned?

Ask for a free Google Ads review. We will check how much of your PMax spend goes on brand and Display, and compare cost per booked job against your Search campaigns.

Get My Free Google Ads Reviewor book a 30-minute call or message us on WhatsApp

CallWhatsApp UsRequest Business Audit